Why AI search favours an integrated marketing approach

The new era of search comes with more acronyms (hello, AEO and GEO), AI overviews revamping the familiar Google’s Search Engine Results Page (SERP) and search queries that have evolved from “Best Italian Restaurant Aberdeen” to “I’m going out for a meal with my friend. We haven’t seen each other in 6 months, she’s vegetarian and we want somewhere with a nice atmosphere. Where should we go? ”.

The way people search has fundamentally changed, going beyond the wording of search queries. By 2027, it is expected that 95% of buyers will begin their research with AI, rather than starting with Google, according to a recent Gartner survey. This represents a significant increase from less than 20% in 2024.

This shift means visibility is no longer driven by search alone. Brands need a more integrated approach, with content, PR, social, reviews and wider third-party signals working together to build authority, reinforce expertise and create a consistent picture of the business across the places people, and increasingly AI, use to inform decisions.

In many ways, good marketing has always done this. The difference now is that the value of having those channels working together is becoming even more apparent.

How brands become discoverable in AI  

Increasingly, customers are reaching the brands they eventually choose much later in the buying journey.

Buyers can now ask an AI assistant to help them understand what is available, compare options, refine their requirements and narrow down their shortlist before ever visiting a company’s website. They can ask follow-up questions, challenge recommendations and explore alternatives without clicking through to a brand at all.

A 6sense report found that the final shortlist is created on day one of the buying journey with buyers purchasing from one of 4 vendors on it in 95% of cases in 2025.

For your website, this means that the traffic that comes through is often much more valuable, with AI traffic converting at three times the rate of traffic from other channels. Instead of introducing your business for the first time, your site is now expected to validate a decision that has already been partially made.

There’s often a misconception that optimising for search engines and optimising for people are two completely different things. They’ve never been identical, but they are closely linked.

Google’s ranking systems have gradually evolved to reward websites that make information easy to find, understand and trust because that’s ultimately what creates a better experience for the person searching.

We’re now seeing something very similar happen with AI visibility.

AI systems process information in a way that is much closer to how humans evaluate recommendations than traditional search algorithms. Rather than relying heavily on a list of keywords and backlinks alone, they look for signals of authority, credibility and consensus across the wider web.

Why the integrated agency approach works

Eli Schwartz put it nicely in one of his weekly newsletters: “When someone asks an LLM for the best analytics tool, the AI doesn’t look up a database of meta tags pairing the word “analytics” with listicles that say “best”. The same is true when someone asks you, as a human, for the best burger in your neighbourhood: you rely on past experiences, social media posts, and friends’ reports to make your recommendation.”

That means it’s no longer enough to simply promote your brand through your own channels, you also need other trusted sources to talk about you.

That could be discussions on Reddit, reviews on Trustpilot or TripAdvisor, mentions in industry publications, guest articles, podcasts or expert commentary. The stronger the independent evidence around your business, the more confidence AI systems have in recommending it.

This is exactly where an integrated marketing strategy proves its value.

SEO, paid search, social media and great website content remain essential. (Digital) PR, thought leadership, partnerships and customer advocacy all contribute to building the wider digital footprint that people and AI increasingly rely on when evaluating a business.

Focusing on one channel in isolation can limit the bigger picture, and the rise of AI search makes integration even more important. That extends beyond digital into PR, partnerships and in-person events. For a while, traditional PR had been pushed to the side to make way for digital, but the power comes from how those channels work together.

Original thinking creates authority

While AI can synthesise existing information, it still depends on people and businesses to create new knowledge. Benchmark reports, customer surveys, industry analysis, proprietary data and expert perspectives all add something new to the conversation.

That matters because authority is built by having something worth saying, sharing and referencing. A strong point of view can become expert commentary in the media, spark discussion on social, earn links and mentions from trusted publications and create opportunities for speaking, podcasts or industry events. Each interaction adds another layer of evidence about who you are, what you know and why you should be trusted.

The brands that consistently contribute original ideas, demonstrate genuine expertise and earn recognition from trusted third parties will be in a much stronger position to be discovered, recommended and chosen.

At Prospect 13, we believe integration has to begin with the strategy. PR, digital, search, content, social and events should all reinforce the same idea. Reputation should be built through consistent, connected activity that makes your brand easier to find, trust and recommend.

Want to build a brand that’s easier to find, trust and recommend?

Let’s talk!

 

 

Picture of Ashleigh

Ashleigh

Marketing Manager

Picture of Hannah

Hannah

Digital Marketing Specialist

Related Posts

COMMUNICATIONS CONSULTANT

LESLEY EATON

At P13, Lesley brings over 35 years of media and communications experience, with a background spanning journalism, editing and PR consultancy.

After graduating from the University of Aberdeen with an MA (Hons.) in Celtic & English, she started out as a reporter before becoming Editor of a weekly local newspaper in Aberdeenshire.

She later moved into PR as the communications lead at Scotland’s largest farmer-owned group of companies, a role that became the perfect stepping stone into freelance consultancy and writing.

Since 2008, Lesley has operated as a freelance PR consultant, successfully juggling projects, deadlines and engaging copy for a wide range of clients.

Organised, experienced and calm under pressure, she knows exactly how to turn words into results.

FOUNDER & CEO

CERRI MCDONALD

Cerri is the Aberdeen quine behind Prospect 13, with a 25-year career in marketing and communications. Before launching P13, she built her career across the energy and tech sectors before climbing to Director level. Then redundancy hit, but instead of crying, Cerri took it as a sign. Very Cerri.

In 2018, she launched Prospect 13 on the belief that SMEs deserved access to strategic marketing expertise without the big agency price tag or corporate bullsh*t. What started as a one-woman mission quickly grew into a team of straight-talking marketers. Now, Cerri leads with strategy, data and insight, with a real passion for getting under the skin of what makes organisations grow.

Outside work, Cerri is mum to Becky and Katy, married to childhood sweetheart Graeme, and happiest eating, drinking, cooking, exercising or planning the next holiday.

Holiday snob? Guilty.

She’s also gone from ‘not the hiking type’ to climbing Kilimanjaro after a knee-jerk decision. Now she’s hooked on Munros and hiking gear. A total foodie, fitness convert, tarot reader, horror fan and crime doc obsessive… and then there is Ness, Cerri’s 3rd baby girl.

DESIGN MANAGER

LISA SIMPSON

Lisa runs Whitespace Studio, a creative studio in Aberdeen specialising in photography and graphic design for brands tired of blending in.

As a Design Manager at Prospect 13 since the beginning, Lisa’s worked across everything from logo design and website builds to marketing campaigns and commercial shoots, helping businesses show up looking sharp.

She’s all about clean design, strong visuals and making the process feel easy, 
no fluff, just good work that delivers results.

Outside of work, she’s usually at the gym or playing taxi driver for her two kids around Aberdeen.

A big fan of a cold sea dip (the colder the better), usually followed by a hot sauna at Aberdeen beach.

Runs almost entirely on tea – and it has to be Tetley. No exceptions.

DIGITAL MARKETING SPECIALIST

HANNAH LOBOCKI

Hannah started her career agency-side as an SEO Executive, building a solid understanding of how people search, what makes content rank and what drives traffic.

After moving in-house into broader marketing roles, she joined Prospect 13 as a Digital Marketing Specialist, bringing a well-rounded, data-led approach to everything she does.

Happiest when digging into user behaviour insights, Hannah is driven by understanding why people do what they do, and how that shows up in the way they move through websites and the wider digital landscape.

Outside of work, she’s into CrossFit, where no two workouts are ever the same.

When she’s not in the gym, she’s out exploring, usually in search of the best oat latte (non-negotiable).

GRAPHIC DESIGNER

CARA MACINTOSH

Cara studied Communication Design at Gray’s School of Art for four years, where her love for graphic design really took shape.

She thrives in creative, collaborative environments and enjoys getting properly stuck into a new project – bringing ideas to life and making them look as good as they should.

Cara joined Prospect 13 in August 2024 after a year at DZD… which has now come full circle, as they’ve since become one of our clients.

Outside of work, you’ll usually find her with her dog Obi, out for a walk or enjoying a bit of downtime.

When she’s not doing that, she’s likely planning, or daydreaming about her next trip to Walt Disney World.

Family life is everything, and she’s happiest spending time with the people closest to her.

CREATIVE CONTENT SPECIALIST

BORYANA CHOBANOVA

At P13, Boryana builds and delivers content strategies that get results. Whether is social media, blogs, case studies, abstracts, campaigns or more, she creates engaging content with high performance. She tracks what’s landing, refines what isn’t and keeps it aligned to drive results.

Boryana works closely with clients and the wider team to keep the marketing strategies moving in line with the deadline, contributing ideas from early planning through to delivery

Outside of work, you can catch her with a book in her hand, at the gym or tuned into a health and wellbeing podcast.

When not tracking client performance, she’s analysing her sleep, running pace, and her ever-growing Duolingo Spanish streak.

Safe to say, she’s always optimising something.

MARKETING MANAGER

ASHLEIGH WALKER

Ashleigh has spent over a decade building a career that blends creativity with commercial thinking. Starting out in graphic design, she later swapped Scotland for Sydney, where she took on a mix of roles and widened her experience.

Back on home soil, she worked with global corporate names including Lockton and Cushman & Wakefield in London before joining Prospect 13 in 2024.

Now, she plays a key role in leading the team and shaping client strategies, bringing creative thinking, direction and commercial awareness, which is a pretty handy mix.

Drawn to Aberdeen by the promise of the quiet life and cheaper booze, Ashleigh quickly found her place in the north-east.

Outside work, you’ll usually find her with Mochi, her wee cocker spaniel, exploring Aberdeenshire… and sipping on a wine.

DIGITAL MARKETING SPECIALIST

ANNIE BUCHAN

Annie is a Digital Marketing Specialist with three years’ experience at P13, starting out as an intern and working part-time while studying for four years at RGU, where she achieved her BA (Hons) in Digital Marketing.

Now full-time, she’s naturally curious (a bit nosey) and loves that digital never stands still, whether it’s analytics, web builds, or fixing problems that seriously test your patience.

Annie loves a good fantasy romance book, going to the gym, and spending time with her friends and family. She’s a big foodie and, in her own words,

“I wake up thinking about fit I’m gan to eat and go to sleep the same why.”

She loves a holiday, snowboarding, partying in Ibiza, or fantasising over Eeyore and Tigger in Disney.

She’s also currently getting ready to welcome her own wee mini me, roll on July!